Is The Newtonian Expectation For Galaxy Rotation Curves Modeled Incorrectly?

The conclusion of this paper is a very big deal if true, and I don't dismiss it out of hand.

But given how well established and widely used the models it claims are grossly wrong are, this needs peer review and time for commentary papers in response to it in order to be taken seriously. I wouldn't be surprised if it contains some significant conceptual flaw.

The approximately flat outer parts of spiral galaxy rotation curves are commonly interpreted as evidence for a discrepancy between the observed baryonic mass and the dynamical mass inferred from the measured orbital velocities. In most standard analyses, this discrepancy is quantified using v2(R)=GM(<R)/R, which is exact only under spherical symmetry. However, spiral galaxies are flattened disk systems, for which mass exterior to the galactocentric radius under consideration can contribute non-negligibly to the gravitational field. 

We introduce the Lost and Found (LF) model, a geometrically consistent Newtonian framework based on direct full-disk gravitational integration and a parametrized representation of the disk surface density. In this approach, the gravitational field is computed without imposing spherical symmetry, and the disk mass distribution is represented by two exponential components with a smooth outer truncation. 

We apply the LF model to a heterogeneous sample of disk galaxies spanning a broad range of masses and radial extents. The model reproduces the main observed features of the rotation curves, including the inner rise and the approximately flat outer behavior, without explicitly invoking a dark matter halo or modifying Newtonian gravity. Across the sample, the LF-inferred mass scales nearly linearly with the conventional dynamical mass, with a characteristic reduction factor ηLF ~ 0.67. 

These results indicate that part of the inferred mass discrepancy may arise from the geometric treatment of gravitation in disk galaxies, and motivate a reassessment of mass inference in non-spherical systems.

Adolfo Santa Fe Dueñas, "Galactic Rotation Curves from Full-Disk Newtonian Gravity: The Lost and Found Model" arXiv:2604.06917 (April 8, 2026) (submitted to MNRAS).