A Central Black Hole's Rotation Direction Doesn't Determine A Galaxy's Rotation Direction

While I didn't have strong expectations one way or the other, this paper's conclusion is potentially important to understanding galaxy formation, and tends to disfavor a purely accretion hypothesis. 

In contrast, the fairly strong correlation between central black hole size and galaxy size tends to argue for a very important role of central black holes in the galaxy formation process, because black holes only make up ca. 1% of a galaxy's mass.

The paper also makes notable observations about other aspects of spiral galaxy geometry.

We compare the apparent directions of rotation in the plane of the sky of active galactic nuclei (AGNs) and their host galaxies. The direction of rotation of the galaxy was inferred from the direction of the spiral arms, while the direction of rotation of the AGN was inferred from spectropolarimetry, where the change in relative polarization position angle (PA) across broad lines is believed to be caused by equatorial scattering. The numbers of co-rotating and counter-rotating AGNs are equal. 

Studies of the relative position angles of radio jets have implied that there is a "zone of avoidance" where jets avoid being in the plane of disk galaxies. We point out that bi-conical narrow-line-region outflows also avoid the plane of the host galaxy. 

The equal numbers of co-rotating and counter-rotating AGNs exclude the hypothesis that the "zone of avoidance" is due to a lack of large tilts of the black hole rotating axis relative to the host galaxy rotation axis. Our results imply that the relative orientations of spin axes are random, at least for the black hole mass range we consider. 

We propose that changes in the broad-line polarization PA with wavelength that do not closely follow the predictions of the simple equatorial scattering model are a consequence of the scattering dust being clumpy. We note a couple of cases of possible changes in PA over several years, which, if real, could be due to motions of the dust clumps or changing anisotropy of the continuum emission.

Loren Gigi, C. Martin Gaskell, "The direction of rotation of supermassive black holes is unrelated to the direction of rotation of the host galaxy" arXiv:2607.06902 (July 8, 2026).