Friday, November 20, 2026

The Ups And Downs Of New Physics Optimism

This new preprint nicely recaps the rise in hope that new physics would be found soon, and the letdown that followed by the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) ruled out the most promising models, especially electroweak scale supersymmetry. 

This contribution is a personal historical retrospective on beyond-the-Standard-Model (BSM) physics from 1978 to the early 2000s, organized around its emotional rollercoaster. I trace two waves of optimism separated by a multiyear contraction of confidence, both ultimately ending in disappointment when decisive experimental confirmation failed to arrive. 
The story begins in 1978, when the Standard Model emerged as the front-runner. It then moves from the first wave of excitement over naturalness and Technicolor, rumored proton-decay events, and the construction of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model, to the contraction of confidence in the late 1980s. A dramatic revival came in 1991, when the LEP and SLC precision data pointed toward supersymmetric unification, but it eventually gave way to renewed disappointment over the absence of superpartners and the sharpening of the LEP paradox. 
I also describe how the realization that Newtonian gravity had been tested only down to distances of order centimeters opened the door to large extra dimensions. Finally, I discuss how Weinberg's 1987 anthropic argument for the cosmological constant, the 1998 discovery of cosmic acceleration, and the emergence of the string landscape changed the intellectual status of naturalness itself and led to Split Supersymmetry. 
I have tried to describe not only what was proposed, but why these ideas felt compelling at the time, why confidence rose and fell, and how later evidence changed our sense of what could count as an explanation.
Savas Dimopoulos, "The BSM Rollercoaster, 1980-2000" arXiv:2611.25060 (November 18, 2026) (Contribution to the 4th International Symposium on the History of Particle Physics, CERN, November 2025).

More On The Impossible Early Galaxies Problem

The impossible early galaxies problem is the fact that we have observed large numbers of relatively large and mature galaxies far earlier than that "standard" Lambda-CDM model of cosmology predicts that we should.

The Initial Mass Function is "an empirical function that describes the initial distribution of masses for a population of stars during star formation. IMF not only describes the formation and evolution of individual stars, it also serves as an important link that describes the formation and evolution of galaxies."

A couple of years ago, Chon, et al., proposed that maybe galaxies formed earlier than expected in a standard Lambda-CDM cosmology because the early universe as an unexpectedly large share of big stars relative to small stars (which is called a "top heavy IMF"). 

A preprint released today determines that while this helps a little at the margins, it isn't nearly a big enough effect to explain how early and often we see galaxies in the very early universe with the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) and the Hubble telescope.

In contrast, models that modify gravity to explain dark matter phenomena, rather than using dark matter particles to explain dark matter phenomena, generically lead to earlier galaxy formation to an extent reasonably approaching what we observe (the exact extent is specific to each modified gravity model). 

A top-heavy stellar initial mass function (IMF) has been proposed to explain the unexpected abundance of ultraviolet (UV)-bright galaxies at cosmic dawn. We test this possibility using the metallicity-dependent, top-heavy IMF recently proposed by Chon et al. (2024), which is motivated by simulations of metal-poor star formation. 
We compare this IMF with a Salpeter IMF, self-consistently including the associated changes in UV emission, supernova feedback, metal enrichment, and dust production. At fixed star formation rate, the Chon IMF enhances the intrinsic UV luminosity by a factor B(1500) ≃ 4.7-2.8 over halo masses M(h) = 10^(8−12) M⊙. However, its larger supernova rate suppresses star formation and increases dust attenuation, reducing the net boost to B(UV) ≃ 2.0-1.06. For halos relevant to the bright end of the UV luminosity function, the enhancement is only B(UV) ≃ 1.2-1.4, or about 0.3 mag. Calculations with the DELPHI semi-analytic model confirm that the self-consistent Chon and Salpeter UV luminosity functions differ by less than 0.5 dex at z≃11-17. 
Thus, a top-heavy IMF alone cannot explain the bright galaxy excess. Conversely, the predicted pair-instability supernova abundance differs by factors of 2-6 between the two IMFs, providing a potentially cleaner observational diagnostic of the high-mass stellar populations at these early epochs.
Andrea Ferrara, Pratika Dayal, "Top-heavy Initial Mass Functions are not enough at cosmic dawn", arXiv:2611.25027 (November 18, 2026) (Submitted to Open Journal of Astrophysics).

Monday, November 9, 2026

Is A Neutrino Anomaly Due To Bad Nuclear Physics Modeling?

It is often the case that a seemingly anomalous result is due to flawed model for making a theoretical prediction of the expected value. The "Gallium anomaly" in neutrino physics might be among them. But a new paper argues that this isn't the problem. This would open the door to beyond the Standard Model neutrino physics (something that I still very much doubt).
The gallium anomaly, a 20% deficit in the measured νe captures on 71Ga, remains unexplained. A recent work [Phys. Rev. Lett. 137, 131805 (2026), arXiv:2512.20560] has proposed a solution based on the breakdown of the factorization of lepton and nuclear wavefunctions that underlies the prediction of the cross section, combined with ad hoc Gamow-Teller nuclear transition densities. 
We test this proposed solution with transition densities calculated within the nuclear shell model (NSM), normalized to the 71Ge electron-capture half-life and convolved with Dirac-Hartree-Fock-Slater electron wavefunctions. We explore several NSM interactions, bare and effective Gamow-Teller operators, as well as the impact of the valence space. In all cases, we obtain remarkably consistent NSM transition densities. Our factorized and nonfactorized cross sections agree, remaining 20% higher than the measured value. In addition, we use NSM single-nucleon transition densities as ansatz and find that solving the anomaly requires fine-tuned densities, with percent-level cancellations and an overall scale orders of magnitude larger than the calculated NSM ones. We conclude that the gallium anomaly is not solved when using realistic nuclear transition densities.
D. Castillo, D. Frycz, J. Menéndez, "Possible Solution to the Gallium Anomaly? Nuclear Transition Densities" arXiv:2611.09788 (November 6, 2026).

MOND and Galaxy Clusters

MOND doesn't work as well in galaxy clusters as it does in individual galaxies. But it is a great improvement over Newtonian gravity without dark matter, even there. And it is closer to the mark than previously assumed now that the amount of interstellar gas has been determined to be underestitimated. This suggests that a fairly modest tweak could make it work in galaxy clusters as well. 
First proposed by Milgrom in 1983 as an alternative to the standard Cold Dark Matter (CDM) paradigm, Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) has gained renewed momentum in light of persistent non-detections of exotic dark matter particles and growing tensions facing CDM on galactic scales. While MOND perfectly reproduces galactic rotation curves, it encounters notable challenges in explaining the equilibrium of galaxy clusters. Although it reduces the overall dark matter budget in these massive systems, an unidentified mass component remains required. 
This paper investigates the hypothesis that this missing mass is baryonic: composed of non-radiating ordinary matter such as stellar remnants, gas too diffuse to initiate star formation, or compact, ultra-dense clouds of cold molecular gas with low volume filling factors. Using a sample of 106 clusters mapped in X-rays, emitted by the hot intra-cluster medium (ICM) composing most of the visible mass, we derive first the total mass within the Newtonian dynamics, assuming hydrostatic equilibrium and spherical symmetry. Then, with the modified Poisson equation, we reconstruct the spatial distribution of the invisible missing matter within the MOND framework. In the sample, the relaxed systems harboring cooling flows, known as cool-core clusters, have the highest peaks of dark missing mass. Its density profile reveals a pronounced central concentration bounded by a steep truncation immediately beyond a core radius of 20-30 kpc, confirming previous studies. 
MOND reduces the necessary dynamical mass by a factor of 4 to 10. The residual missing mass is proportional to the total gas mass, being roughly twice lower.
Francoise Combes, "Modified Newtonian Dynamics and galaxy clusters" arXiv:2611.08702 (November 5, 2026) (accepted in PNAS (Inaugural article)).

There Are A Lot Of Dark Matter Models Out There

There are more than six thousand dark matter models floating out there in theory space. This is a lot, but it is also eminently finite. So, it makes sense that AI is a good tool to use to start making sense of them. But AI is not terribly accurate (81%), even though, in this case, it didn't actually hallucinate any new models.

Of course, there is only one right answer (which isn't guaranteed to be any of the models proposed so far), and a large share of them are ruled out be existing evidence (of which the creators of many models weren't necessarily aware).


To use a dark-matter model one needs to know what defines it, which observables it affects, which codes and likelihoods evaluate it, and under what assumptions a published bound applies. That information is scattered across tens of thousands of papers. 
We present DarkMatterFM-Registry, a machine-readable registry of dark-matter models extracted from arXiv full texts by a staged large-language-model (LLM) pipeline: 6,145 structured model cards, validated against a seven-file JSON Schema suite, ranked by expected value for observational follow-up, and enriched for the top ~2,000 with observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes. 
Schema checks pass 97.8% of cards, and an LLM-judged accuracy study on a stratified card sample finds 81% of section verdicts correct, 18% partially correct, and none hallucinated. 
As a first application we turn the registry into a priority-weighted roadmap of 25 concrete projects the community could build. The roadmap is built by judging every computational step of every enriched model's theory-to-observable routes as available, partial, or missing, and aggregating the resulting typed gaps weighted by model priority. 
We find that what blocks the most high-priority models is not missing theory but missing shared infrastructure: model files for existing relic-abundance solvers, a general non-cold Boltzmann-code framework, reusable indirect-detection likelihoods, and a Lyman-α forest likelihood for non-cold dark matter (the largest gap for structure-formation probes). The model cards, schemas, roadmap, and ranking are released making the project reproducible and the cards available for the community.
Ioana A. Zelko, Jo Bovy, Nolan Koblischke, "DarkMatterFM-Registry: A Machine-Readable Registry of Dark-Matter Models Extracted from the arXiv Literature" arXiv:2611.08583 (November 5, 2026)  (Accepted at the Machine Learning and the Physical Sciences Workshop (ML4PS), NeurIPS 2026. Registry, schemas, and code: this https URL).