The impossible early galaxies problem is the fact that we have observed large numbers of relatively large and mature galaxies far earlier than that "standard" Lambda-CDM model of cosmology predicts that we should.
The Initial Mass Function is "an empirical function that describes the initial distribution of masses for a population of stars during star formation. IMF not only describes the formation and evolution of individual stars, it also serves as an important link that describes the formation and evolution of galaxies."
A couple of years ago, Chon, et al., proposed that maybe galaxies formed earlier than expected in a standard Lambda-CDM cosmology because the early universe as an unexpectedly large share of big stars relative to small stars (which is called a "top heavy IMF").
A preprint released today determines that while this helps a little at the margins, it isn't nearly a big enough effect to explain how early and often we see galaxies in the very early universe with the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) and the Hubble telescope.
In contrast, models that modify gravity to explain dark matter phenomena, rather than using dark matter particles to explain dark matter phenomena, generically lead to earlier galaxy formation to an extent reasonably approaching what we observe (the exact extent is specific to each modified gravity model).
A top-heavy stellar initial mass function (IMF) has been proposed to explain the unexpected abundance of ultraviolet (UV)-bright galaxies at cosmic dawn. We test this possibility using the metallicity-dependent, top-heavy IMF recently proposed by Chon et al. (2024), which is motivated by simulations of metal-poor star formation.
We compare this IMF with a Salpeter IMF, self-consistently including the associated changes in UV emission, supernova feedback, metal enrichment, and dust production. At fixed star formation rate, the Chon IMF enhances the intrinsic UV luminosity by a factor B(1500) ≃ 4.7-2.8 over halo masses M(h) = 10^(8−12) M⊙. However, its larger supernova rate suppresses star formation and increases dust attenuation, reducing the net boost to B(UV) ≃ 2.0-1.06. For halos relevant to the bright end of the UV luminosity function, the enhancement is only B(UV) ≃ 1.2-1.4, or about 0.3 mag. Calculations with the DELPHI semi-analytic model confirm that the self-consistent Chon and Salpeter UV luminosity functions differ by less than 0.5 dex at z≃11-17.
Thus, a top-heavy IMF alone cannot explain the bright galaxy excess. Conversely, the predicted pair-instability supernova abundance differs by factors of 2-6 between the two IMFs, providing a potentially cleaner observational diagnostic of the high-mass stellar populations at these early epochs.
Andrea Ferrara, Pratika Dayal, "Top-heavy Initial Mass Functions are not enough at cosmic dawn", arXiv:2611.25027 (November 18, 2026) (Submitted to Open Journal of Astrophysics).

No comments:
Post a Comment