All the GUTs Worth Considering

A fairly short new paper (five pages plus seven pages of footnotes and an appendix) tries to list most or all of the possible Grand Unified Theories a.k.a. GUTs (i.e. theories the unify the three Lie groups of the Standard Model, but not gravity, into a single unified mathematical structure; unified theories that also include gravity are called Theories of Everything a.k.a. TOEs) that could include the Standard Model of Particle Physics, or an extension of it. 

There aren't all that many possibilities that are promising, and several decades of attempts to fit the Standard Model into one in a way that provides useful theoretical insight has not been very fruitful. While this line of inquiry isn't as troubled as supersymmetry (which is a dead man walking) or string theory (which is almost as troubled), it isn't very "hot" either.

Many potential GUTs, including the most minimal SU(5) GUT, would (1) imply violations of baryon number and/or lepton number conservation that aren't observed (e.g. proton decay, flavor changing neutral currents, and neutrinoless double beta decay), (2) lack some fundamental particles that are observed in the Standard Model, or (3) imply the existence of new fundamental particles beyond the Standard Model that haven't been observed (and in some cases, these particles have been ruled out to quite high energies). 

As a general rule, the bigger the Lie group of the unifying GUT, the more likely it is that it will imply far more new fundamental particles than there is any good reason to think that even a many particle dark sector should contain. Theoretical physicists prefer GUTs that imply as minimal an extension of the Standard Model as possible. Moreover, GUTs with certain kinds of new fundamental particles, such as those that imply more than three generations of fundamental Standard Model fermions, are strongly disfavored.

The experimental constraints on baryon number violating and lepton number violating processes (outside sphaleron interactions which are predicted in the Standard Model at extremely high energies but have not been observed) like proton decay, flavor changing neutral currents, and neutrinoless double beta decay are both very strict and very robust (i.e. they have been tested in multiple, independent ways). The exclusions of new fundamental particles are generally up to masses of several hundred to many thousands of GeVs, which is less strict, and the possibility of beyond the Standard Model fundamental particles is also strongly motivated (although not compelled) by the existence of dark matter phenomena. 

In the early days of GUT theories, a much sought after GUT property was that the three Standard Model forces unify at high enough energies in a manner that echos electroweak unification theory (which was one of the very attractive features of supersymmetry theory). But this has also been elusive. 

The Standard Model beta functions of the three Standard Model forces (electromagnetism, the weak force, and the strong force), which govern how the strength of these forces change with energy scale, extrapolated to arbitrarily high energy scales, based upon data all of the way up to the energy scales that can be reached by the Large Hadron Collider a.k.a. LHC (the highest energy scale high energy physics experiment every conducted), never unify. So, if a GUT the unifies the three Standard Model forces exists is some high energy scale, this must be due to new physics at energy scales above those that can be experimentally probed so far that is outside the domain of applicability of the Standard Model. 

Basically, given the energy scales that have already been reached by the LHC, energies at which the three Standard Model force could possibly unify haven't been present anywhere in the universe since some fraction of a second elapsed after the Big Bang. Of course, it is entirely possible that the three Standard Model forces simply don't unify at any energy scale that has ever existed or ever could exist.

Under a reasonable set of ab-initio assumptions, we define and chart the atlas of simple gauge theories with families of fermions whose masses are forbidden by gauge invariance. We propose a compass to navigate the atlas based on counting degrees of freedom. When searching for Grand-unification Theories with three matter generations, the free energy singles out the SU(5) Georgi-Glashow model as the minimal one, closely followed by SO(10) with spinorial matter. The atlas also defines the dryland of grand-unifiable gauge extensions of the standard model. We further provide examples relevant for gauge dual completions of the standard model as well as extensions by an additional SU(N) gauge symmetry.

Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Aldo Deandrea, Konstantinos Kollias, Francesco Sannino, "Grand-unification Theory Atlas: Standard Model and Beyond" arXiv:2507.06368 July 8, 2025).

The final paragraph of the conclusion of the main paper also enumerates some limitations on this paper serving as a truly comprehensive list of possibilities:

We have not considered yet scalar fields, as their mass cannot be prevented by any symmetry. Including spontaneous symmetry breaking of the gauge symmetry and generation of Yukawa couplings could imprint further constraints on the atlas, providing a phenomenological compass to navigate us towards the optimal high-energy theory. In our analysis, asymptotic freedom plays a crucial role in counting the degrees of freedom of each theory.